What is a poet? An unhappy man who hides deep anguish in his heart, but whose lips are so formed that when the sigh and cry pass through them, it sounds like lovely music…. And people flock around the poet and say: ‘Sing again soon’ – that is, ‘May new sufferings torment your soul but your lips be fashioned as before, for the cry would only frighten us, but the music, that is blissful.
Søren Kierkegaard
In the introduction to The Crucible, Arthur Miller suggests that the Puritans lacked a system for forgiveness and renewal; mistakes, then, were condemnable. The harsh reality of their lives might have called for tall moral codes that could not allow for any lapses in discipline. He suggests, further, that we [Americans] have inherited a system of unforgiveness from them. We have no real system for confession and renewal, and so many of us make a mistake and begin an awful rowing toward shame and resentment. The result is broken lives, broken families, broken societies, and stagnant culture. 1
The scripture above2 describes the way religionists tend to be “whitewashed tombs”; religionists keep up an outward appearance of righteousness–and can often live nearly spotless lives–while they are wasting away inside. They are like Napoleon on St Helen: an English servant is paid to put a pinch of arsenic in his wine, until he wastes away and dies. It’s like the wine of the eucharist (“good gift”) is gently-laced with arsenic–resentment, bitterness, shame, and a whole host of apostalary suppression–and the tribe slowly dies.
But this is not solely an endemic of organized religion. It is a trait of both the American secularist and religionist to adopt unrelenting, unattainable moral standards for himself and others, until we he hates himself, or the other, and dies on island of the mother of Constantine.
This is where the misfits, outcasts, dropouts, failures, and fools come in. Through a black sheep’s estrangement, he has the power to redeem a family emotional ambassador. I’ve heard a number of stories of young women (and some men), who’ve overcome eating disorders and so scared the hell out of the family.
A system had operated, and one individual had inherited the shame of the family system, shattered the “idealized family” and emerged with emotional wholeness. These individuals are not only walking testimonies of the courage to heal, but they become emotional ambassadors for the culture. While their siblings and peers are amassing credentials, money, status–”righteousness,” if you will–they are suffering the slings and arrows of their outrageous fortune. The pain of feeling “less than” in their accomplishments is assuaged by their emotional power, and their emotional empowerment can and often makes them ambassadors in their homes.
They often become both the priest who “atones” for generational and social wrong-doing and the prophet who creates a vision and an atmosphere for healing. If you feel like a black sheep I’d consider the potentia (power-potential) of your role as an emotional ambassador; if you are a “golden child,” I’d consider the priestly and prophetic potential of your sibling or peer.
It’s good that our country has established precedents and infrastructure for reconciliations between nations. But we are an infirm nation, and our culture has devolved into a necrophiliac fascination with violence (Criminal Minds, Law and Order, CSI NY, LV, Fresno, wherever the hell), and sadistic fascination with destructive sex. It is the broken, the misfits, the failures, the dropouts and the fools who have the powerful mandate to craft healing. This seems to begin with self-forgiveness, extends naturally to relational forgiveness. On the grandscale (and in the landscape of my imagination) this becomes a vision is for social forgiveness cultural renewal.






